Unexpected item: how self-checkout turned me into an unpaid employee
The supermarket fired the cashier and hired you. Nobody told you.
By Nico Ferraz · Published · 2 min read
Yesterday I got fired from a job I never had. Let me explain.
I went into the supermarket to buy four things: bread, coffee, soap and a banana. One. I'm a 61-year-old man, I don't need a bunch. At the exit there was one human register open and a line that started back at the bakery. Next to it, eight glowing screens, calling me like sirens.
I went.
The job I didn't apply for
Look at what happened. The cashier — trained, doing this eight hours a day, knows the banana code by heart — was replaced by me. Me: no training, no badge, no paycheck. And no stool. She had a stool. I stood there holding a banana like it was evidence.
Arthur, who was with me and is incapable of experiencing anything without measuring it, timed me: four items in seven minutes and forty seconds. According to him, an experienced cashier would do it in under a minute. "You are the least productive employee in the history of retail," he said. Thanks, Arthur. At least I'm free.
"Unexpected item in the bagging area"
Then the machine spoke to me. In that calm voice of someone who has never stood in line: unexpected item in the bagging area.
Unexpected? It was a banana. A banana is the most expected thing on Earth. Monkeys expect bananas. Grocery stores expect bananas. Bananas are so expected they come pre-wrapped.
Arthur explained, with the patience of a man who has rejected 2.3 million parts: the bagging-area scale compares the expected weight with the weight you put down. It was off by twelve grams. Twelve grams! I told him that was my dignity leaving the building. It weighs exactly twelve grams. He wrote it down in his notebook.
The lady with the badge
The screen froze and a little red light came on above my head. A red light. Above an older gentleman. Holding a banana. Everybody looked.
Then the lady with the badge came to unlock it. And who was the lady with the badge? The same lady from the register. She wasn't fired; she was promoted to old-man supervisor. The company didn't eliminate her job; now she works and I work. The only system in history where you add an employee and nobody gets paid more.
The final question
At the end, after the receipt, the screen asked: "How was your experience?" With little faces. Green, yellow, red.
Arthur gave it a rating. I asked what he gave it. He looked at the screen and said, without blinking: "Unexpected item."
I have nothing against technology. I was a radio host; I lived on technology. What I won't accept is technology that hands the work to me and the profit to someone else, and then wants to know if I enjoyed it.
Frequently asked questions
Is self-checkout always bad?
No. If you're buying three things in a hurry, it can be great. The problem starts when it becomes the only option and the system treats every customer like a suspect.
Why does the scale say "unexpected item"?
Usually the bagging area compares the expected weight of the product with the weight placed in the bag. Any difference outside the tolerance freezes the transaction until someone overrides it.
About the author
Hosted "Nico After Midnight" on AM radio for 30 years. He doesn't want to fix the world; he wants to know who signed off on it. Owns a dog named Manager so he can always ask to speak to the Manager.
Fictional character from The Fed Up Buddies universe.
More nonconformities
The Flawed Blueprint
Airplane boarding is the worst logistics project ever approved by human beings
We board airplanes like filling a bottle through the neck, in the wrong order, with everyone carrying a bag that doesn't fit. I redesigned the process. Nobody will use it.
Arthur Bastos ·
Letters to Management
A letter to the management of the yogurt lid
Dear management: the yogurt lid tore into three pieces, none of them useful, and I ended up eating the product with my fingertip. Please find my formal complaint below.
Arthur Bastos ·
It Was Bad Back Then Too
It was bad back then too: payphones, coins and a whole afternoon in the bank line
Some people miss a time when paying a bill took an afternoon and calling home required coins, luck and a payphone that wasn't broken. We remember. We don't miss it.
Nico Ferraz ·